Ale Vs. Lager

Published on June 25th 2021 by SNBC

Hops often enjoy the limelight with craft beer, but yeast is the foundation of your pint. More than driving the creation of alcohol—a big deal, no doubt—yeast also produces flavor and aroma compounds toward the finished beer. And it’s specific types of yeast responsible for the two main fermentation groups: ale and lager.

What is ale?

Brewing an ale requires a yeast species named Saccharomyces cerevisiae, commonly called “top fermenting” because as the yeast eats up malt-derived sugars, it rises to the top of the vessel in a layer of foam. Those vessels might be fully closed to the air; there are also “open fermenters” where ales like Bigfoot Barleywine are known to put on a real show.

Looking skyward at 800-barrel fermentation tanks at Sierra Nevada Brewing Co.

Ale yeast foams and froths in open fermentation tanks at Sierra Nevada Brewing Co.

There are many kinds of ale thanks to different strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. From IPAs to wheat beers and Belgian styles, craft brewers can select the ideal yeast for their recipes. Our Pale Ale and Hazy Little Thing IPA, for example, have mild yeast character while Kellerweis is all about the notes of spicy clove and banana bread from its unique yeast.

A flask of bubbling Hefeweizen yeast next to a six-pack of Sierra Nevada Kellerweis

Clove and banana aromas are examples of “esters,” a fermentation byproduct that appears in both ales and lagers, but ales tend to produce more. One reason is that ale yeast typically ferments at a higher temperature than lager yeast, between 60–75 ºF. This range keeps ale yeast happy and productive, fostering more of those fruity aromas that can include pear, apple, and even rose.

What is lager?

Lager turns ale on its head—lager is “bottom fermenting”—and uses a yeast called Saccharomyces pastorianus. Lager yeast thrives at lower temperatures than ale, generally between 42–55 ºF. It’s a slower and calmer process, so lager yeast sinks to the bottom of the vessel; ale yeast, with its warmer fermentation, is more vigorous and shoots to the top.

And while ale yeast can be found in nature (e.g., on ripe fruits), lager yeast has more colorful origins.

“It arose in a timescale of hundreds of years when an ale strain ‘partied’ in a brewery with a wine yeast called Saccharomyces eubayanus,” explains Charlie Bamforth, our Senior Quality Advisor and Pope of Foam. “A more complex melded organism was produced, one with 50% more genetic information than the parent ale yeast.”

Like ales, there’s a bounty of distinct lagers including Czech- and German-style Pilsners, malty Dunkels, and modern creations like India Pale Lager (IPL). Each year we brew a seasonal Oktoberfest lager to celebrate the world’s biggest beer party, and there’s no better way to welcome spring than with our golden lager Pale Bock.

A goat rests its head next to a four-pack of Sierra Nevada Pale Bock beer

What are the key differences?

Lager means “to store” and alludes to the extra patience this beer requires. Before the arrival of refrigeration, brewers targeted the cooler months for their craft; they fermented and lagered beer in caves or cellars ahead of summer thirst.

So how much longer does it take? With a lager like our Oktoberfest, it’s 21–28 days from the start of brewing to final packaging. On the other hand, our numerous ales like Torpedo IPA or Narwhal Imperial Stout are a comparatively speedy 14–18 days.

A young man holds out a glass of Sierra Nevada Narwhal Imperial Stout

Lager’s prolonged fermentation also results in fewer byproducts (remember esters?), leading to a beer most drinkers perceive as crisper than an ale, with more nuance to its flavor and aroma.

But you’ll find plenty of beers that fall outside the guardrails of ale and lager. German-style Kolsch, for example, is fermented with ale yeast before maturing in colder lager conditions. You get a crisp and clean pint with hints of fruit or spice that recall an ale. (A style called California Common is the inverse: lager yeast fermented like an ale.) And when you hear “Porter,” you might assume an ale, but the Baltic-style Porter is cold-fermented with lager yeast. It’s oh so smooth, with the richness and roast of an Imperial Stout.

A can of Baltic Joy Porter resting on a bed of almonds and coconut

Hop character can vary between ales and lagers too. It might feel like it at times, but India Pale Ale doesn’t have a monopoly on hoppiness. There are traditional lagers that elevate hops, like the Czech-style Pilsner whose late additions of Saaz hops yield a pleasant, spicy aroma. And a hybrid like India Pale Lager—as it sounds: a lager booming with hops—reinforces craft brewers’ spirit of exploration. Hoppy Lager is a cherished recipe in our archive.

And perhaps it’s obvious which is stronger: ale or lager? You might be surprised. Yes, lots of lagers out there have a low ABV, which makes them great session beers. But move up the scale and substantial lagers await, including our Pale Bock (6.8% ABV) and Baltic Joy Porter (7.8% ABV). They’re no Hoptimum Triple IPA (11% ABV), but you can’t underestimate ales or lagers!

An explosive, hoppy ale. A delicate, crisp lager. Something in between. Whatever you’re craving now, track it down with our Beer Finder.

Find Beer Near You



This is a carousel. Use Next and Previous buttons to navigate.

Loading …
More Stories